diff options
| author | Federico Igne <federico.igne@cs.ox.ac.uk> | 2020-11-19 10:23:13 +0000 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Federico Igne <federico.igne@cs.ox.ac.uk> | 2020-11-19 10:23:13 +0000 |
| commit | d9511b4f3742ae9f4b8f589bd154159d7a45b944 (patch) | |
| tree | 2f3ec1af9d6136a152fb7d47b84482ed447d1316 | |
| parent | 1efc189e90240c162b54cbc50362b46786643dad (diff) | |
| download | RSAComb-d9511b4f3742ae9f4b8f589bd154159d7a45b944.tar.gz RSAComb-d9511b4f3742ae9f4b8f589bd154159d7a45b944.zip | |
Update README.md
| -rw-r--r-- | README.md | 37 |
1 files changed, 32 insertions, 5 deletions
| @@ -35,11 +35,38 @@ We tried to implement the system as close as possible to the theoretical descrip | |||
| 35 | Regardless, we had to deal with the fact that we where using different tools to carry out reasoning tasks and we where probably using a different language to implement the system. | 35 | Regardless, we had to deal with the fact that we where using different tools to carry out reasoning tasks and we where probably using a different language to implement the system. |
| 36 | The following is a summary of fixes (🔧), changes (🔄) and improvements (⚡), we introduced along the way: | 36 | The following is a summary of fixes (🔧), changes (🔄) and improvements (⚡), we introduced along the way: |
| 37 | 37 | ||
| 38 | + 🔧 FIX | 38 | + 🔄 [RDFox](https://www.oxfordsemantic.tech/product) is used instead of DLV as the underlying LP engine. |
| 39 | 39 | ||
| 40 | + 🔄 CHANGE | 40 | + 🔧 In [[1](#references) - Def.4], the definition of built-in predicate `notIn` is wrong and should reflect the implicit semantics implied by the name, i.e., "let [...] `notIn` be a built-in predicate which holds when the first argument is **not** an element of the set given as second argument". |
| 41 | 41 | This has been fixed by (1) introducing a built-in predicate `In` (note that instances of `In` can be computed beforehand since they only depend on the input ontology), and (2) implement `notIn` as the negation of `In` using RDFox NaF built-in support. | |
| 42 | + âš¡ IMPROVEMENT | 42 | |
| 43 | + 🔄 Top (`owl:Thing`) axiomatisation is performed introducing rules as follows. | ||
| 44 | Given *p* predicate (arity *n*) *in the original ontology*, the following rule is introduced: | ||
| 45 | ``` | ||
| 46 | owl:Thing[?X1], *...*, owl:Thing[?Xn] :- *p*(?X1, *...*, ?Xn) . | ||
| 47 | ``` | ||
| 48 | Note that by definition arity can be either 1 or 2. | ||
| 49 | |||
| 50 | + 🔄 Equality axiomatisation is performed introducing the following rules: | ||
| 51 | ``` | ||
| 52 | rsa:congruent[?X, ?X] :- owl:Thing[?X] . | ||
| 53 | rsa:congruent[?Y, ?X] :- rsa:congruent[?X, ?Y] . | ||
| 54 | rsa:congruent[?X, ?Z] :- rsa:congruent[?X, ?Y], rsa:congruent[?Y, ?Z] . | ||
| 55 | ``` | ||
| 56 | defining equivalence as a congruence relation over terms in the ontology. | ||
| 57 | *Substitution rules have not been entroduced yet.* | ||
| 58 | |||
| 59 | + 🔧 In [[1](#references) - Def. 4], the definition of built-in predicate `NI` is not consistent with its use in [[1](#references) - Table 3] and related description in [[1](#references) - Sec. 4.2]. | ||
| 60 | We redefined `NI` as the set of all constants that are *equal* to a constant in the original ontology (according to the internal equality predicate `rsa:congruent`). | ||
| 61 | Note that, in this scenario, there is no need to introduce `NI` instances as facts in the system; | ||
| 62 | instead we can add a rule to populate the new predicate: | ||
| 63 | ``` | ||
| 64 | NI[?X] :- rsa:congruent[?X, ?Y], rsa:named[?Y] . | ||
| 65 | ``` | ||
| 66 | where `rsa:named` is an internal predicate keeping track of all constants in the original ontology. | ||
| 67 | |||
| 68 | + 🔄 While the system is described as a two-step process (computing the canonical model and applying the filtering program), the adoption of RDFox allows us to abstract from the underlying engine implementation. | ||
| 69 | Materialisation is handled by RDFox, possibly computing answers in one go, without splitting the process in two separate steps. | ||
| 43 | 70 | ||
| 44 | ## References | 71 | ## References |
| 45 | 72 | ||
